Message of inclusion not just 'disputed'
- it's 'urgent'
its television ads, the UCC bears witness to a deep evangelical impulse
that is already rooted in the commandment of Sinai: "Love your neighbor."
Of course there are, in the Bible and beyond the Bible, endless wonderments
about the identity of our neighbor. There is no doubt, however, that the
deepest impulse of the Bible is toward inclusion, that all of God's creatures
be accorded dignity, respect, safety and a sense of belonging. That deep
biblical impulse gives the church its primal mandate, a summons reflected
in these ads.
The issue of inclusion is not only disputed among us; it also is urgent.
It is urgent because we U.S. Christians live in a society that is profoundly
exclusionary in ways that debilitate. While we popularly celebrate the
large vision of democracy among us, it is the case that the reality of
socio-economic-political power works primarily to divide and exclude,
to distinguish between "haves" and "have-nots" so that the "haves" always
have more and more and the "have-nots" have less and less.
The same exclusionary propensity in our society is evident in the fear
of "immigrants," even if we maintain our ambiguous response because the
fear of new immigrants is curbed by the usefulness of cheap labor. On
issues of race, ethnicity and class, there works among us a vision of
a safe society that consists only in people "like us," a phrase that most
often refers to the ruling class of white Euro-Americans.
That same exclusionary propensity that violates both "the American dream"
and the gospel is now alive and well in the U.S. church, albeit with a
kind of moral ferociousness that is not matched in the civic community.
The fear of "the other" in the realm of U.S. religion now pertains not
only to race, class and ethnicity, but also to sexual identity; as the
church practices God's holiness, it finds that sexuality is in odd and
deep ways linked to holiness.
In the face of such an exclusionary inclination rooted in fear and in
inchoate anxiety, a church faithful to the gospel is summoned by the Lord
of the church to challenge such exclusion and to practice an inclusiveness
that is as broad as humanity and as deep as God's generosity. In the current
"battle for the Bible," biblical texts and themes that witness to God's
generous inclusiveness are not much known or cited among us:
In Isaiah 56, the prophetic poem reflects an argument about inclusion
and exclusion. The prophet witnesses to inclusion by insisting that foreigners
and eunuchs - "others" in an ordered Jewish community - are to be welcomed
precisely because the community gathered around God is "for all peoples."
Do not let the foreigner joined to the Lord say, "The Lord will surely
separate me from his people;" and do not let the eunuch say, "I am just
a dry tree." For thus says the Lord: To the eunuchs who keep my sabbaths,
who choose the things that please me and hold fast my covenant, I will
give, in my house and within my walls, a monument and a name better than
sons and daughters; I will give them an everlasting name that shall not
be cut off. (Isa 56:3-5)
The New Testament church early faced the same issue as it moved beyond
its Jewish origins to include all those loved by God, even Gentiles who
were for some the abhorrent "other." Thus it is reported in Acts 10 that
Peter - that great stalwart of the proper church - was visited by God
in a dream and urged to accept what his community had regarded as "unclean."
We may imagine that the dream from God was deeply upsetting and that Peter
found the mandate shocking: The voice said to him again, a second time,
"What God has made clean, you must not call profane." (Acts 10:15)
But Peter obeyed! And since the time of Peter, the church in its faithfulness
has refused fearful, societal categories and has been open to this practice
of God's graciousness.
Alongside Peter, Paul became the great missionary for evangelical openness,
recognizing - against his own fearful tradition - that none can be ejected
from the church because they threaten us and are unlike us. Paul draws
the conclusion: For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek; the
same Lord is Lord of all and is generous to all who call on him. (Rom
The Jewish church had to make room for the very Gentiles it recognized
it had categorized as "impure." So in our day, conservatives must make
room for liberals and, in a harder challenge for our church, liberals
must make room for conservatives. And all must make room together for
those whom society dismisses as "impure."
Out of Paul's new awareness there came an inclusionary trajectory in
the church, not uncontested but eventually accepted. We are offered, in
the letter to the Ephesians, a new characterization of holiness that is
not related to race, ethnicity or any other category of uncleanness, but
rather to participation in a community of grace, tenderness, forgiveness
And do not grieve the Holy Spirit of God, with which you were marked
with a seal for the day of redemption. Put away from you all bitterness
and wrath and anger and wrangling and slander, together with all malice,
and be kind to one another, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, as
God in Christ has forgiven you. Therefore be imitators of God, as beloved
children. (Eph 4:30-5:1)
Such a practice, in an exclusionary religious scene amid an exclusionary
society that is fearful of the other, is an enormous challenge to the
church. A bent toward inclusion runs great risks, but they are risks faithful
to the gospel. In the long run such risks serve the kingdom. In the short
run, they are the requirements of fidelity among us. Such fidelity will
every time override fear and every time subvert anxiety. In doing so we
remember that he said, "I tell you, do not be anxious."
Rev. Walter Brueggemann, a UCC minister and scholar who authored
more than 25 books on the Bible, is a professor emeritus at Columbia
Theological Seminary in Atlanta.
© 2005 The
United Church of Christ
Reposted with permission from United
Original article: http://www.ucc.org/ucnews/jan06/bible.htm
Copyright © by the author
All Rights Reserved
Back to the Table of Contents